Vierteljahrschrift für Sozial- und Wirtschaftsgeschichte

 

VSWG

 

zurück zur Stammseite

• Richtlinien für die Erstellung der Beiträge

• Inhalt des letzten Heftes

• geplante Beiträge

• Gesamtinhaltsverzeichnis

 

 

 

 

Abstracts (Band 89/2002 und 90/2003)

 

Wolfgang Ayaß: Bismarck und der Arbeiterschutz. Otto von Bismarcks Áblehnung des gesetzlichen Arbeiterschutzes - eine Analyse der Dimensionen und Hintergründe (Band 89, Seite 400)

Bismarck and te protective Labor Legislation

 

The eighteen-eighties under Chancellor Otto von Bismarck saw the establishment of statutory workers’ insurance in Germany. Germany remained backwards, however, in the statutory protection of workers at their workplace, the prevention of dangers arising from industrial work, and the limitation of hours of work for children, young persons, women or even workers in general. The protection of young workers, for example, remained until 1891 as it had been in 1853. That was due to the fundamental refusal of all improvements in matters of regulations for the protection of workers on the part of Bismarck, who blocked all relevant initiatives. Along with other sources this article draws on previously rarely used marginalia of Bismarck’s in ministerial documents on factory inspection, children’s and women’s labour, the prohibition of Sunday work, and the introduction of a standard working day. The investigation deals with the Chancellor’s motives and the arguments deployed in his prevention of measures of workers’ protection, which he called an infringement of workers’ freedom of action.

 

Marcel Boldorf: Entwicklung und institutionelle Rahmenbedingungen: Die Beispiele Niederschlesien und Nordirland (1750–1850) (Band 90/2003, S. 399)

Institutions and Economic Development: The Cases of Lower Silesia and Northern Ireland (1750–1850)

 

The focus of this article is on the institutional arrangements which influenced the costs to merchants. The guilds of the Silesian town-based merchants, acting as a cartel, lowered the costs of linen purchase. Furthermore, they could successfully suppress the development of a putting-out-system around the centralized markets. There were neither widespread process innovations nor product innovations in Silesia, like, for instance, fine linens (damask). As a consequence, there was a lack of entrepreneurial initiative at the threshold of industrialisation. In contrast, Ulster was an example of a rather successful development because of the absence of guilds and restrictive regulations. Thus, the comparative analysis can explain industrialisation or de-industrialisation within European regional development.

 

Markuks A. Denzel: Die Geschäftsbeziehungen des Schaffhauser Handels- und Bankhauses Amman 1748<—1779. Ein mikroökonomisches Fallbeispiel (Band 89, Seite 1)

The Trade Relations of the Schaffhausen Merchant-Banker Amman 1748—1779. A Micro-Economic Case Study

 

The micro-economic investigation of the Schaffhausen merchant-banker Amman gives a good example of the great importance smaller enterprises could have within the Europe-wide trading network even without being based in the big and international centres of business, commercial and financial activities. It shows how much the European trade and payment was dependent on such ‚small’ merchant-bankers which functioned as intermediaries between economic regions and international ‚super-companies’. The study deals with the question how the individual parts of the Amman business developed throughout the period of investigation, special stress will be put on the changing ‚positioning’ of this merchant-banker within the network of business partners reaching over large parts of Western and Central Europe.

 

Markus A. Denzel und Hans-Jürgen Gerhard: Inflationäre Prozesse in Nordwestdeutschland im 18. Jahrhundert - Professor Dr. Karl Heinrich Kaufhold zum 70. Geburtstag (Band 90, S. 1)

 

This article wants to describe some of the inflationary processes appearing in the 18th century in the Holy Roman Empire and to survey their causes as well as their backgrounds. It is the objective of research to show how far inflationary processes went off either similarly or differently in Hamburg – the single German port of global importance – as well as in Lower Saxon territories in the Hamburg hinterland – perhaps even independently of one another – and to find out the decisive local, regional or international factors. The research is carried out with baskets of goods containing for Hamburg as well as for its hinterland each time about 30 different products.

 

Rainer Fremdling / Reiner Stäglin: Die Industrieerhebung von 1936: Ein Input-Output-Ansatz zur Rekonstruktion der volkswirtschaftlichen Gesamtrechnung für Deutschland im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert - Ein Arbeitsbericht (Band 90, S. 416)

 

The Industrial Survey of 1936: An input-Output Approach for the Reconstruction of the National Accounts of Germany in the 19th and 20th Century - a Working Report

 

Karl Christian Führer: Das NS-Rgime und die "Idealform des deutschen Wohnungsbaues". Ein Beitrag zur nationalsozialistischen Gesellschaftspolitik (Band 89, Seite 141)

 

The Natinal Socialist Regime and the "Ideal Form of German Housing". A Contribution to the Debate on the Social Politics of Nazism

The article outlines the history of the Kleinsiedlungen (smallholdings) in National Socialist Germany, a special form of accommodation that was commonly regarded as the ideal of housing for practical as well as for ideological reasons since 1933. However, grandiose schemes to build hundreds of thousands or even millions of smallholdings failed; in reality the Kleinsiedlungen formed only a small part of the new housing production. This failure can be put down to the racist policies of the NSDAP and to the party’s fixation on military strength as the most important political task. The National Socialist regime could not react to any of the manifold practical problems that obstructed the smallholding schemes since all these problems were caused by the regime itself. The essay thus contributes to the on-going debate on National Socialist domestic policy and argues that the NSDAP was in principle unable to pursue a policy of constructive social reform.

 

William D. Godsey, Jr.: Adelsversorgung in der Neuzeit: Die Wiederbelebung des Deutschen Ritterordens in der österreichischen Restauration (Band 90, S. 25)

 

During the revolutionary era 1789-1815, the nobility in the core territories of the Habsburg Empire underwent no fundamental structural changes such as the nobility in the rest of Central Europe experienced. Unlike in Germany, manorial rights, patrimonial jurisdiction, and estatist constitutions remained mostly untouched there, as did many time-honored supports of the traditional understanding of nobility such as collegiate foundations and honors at Court, both of which required proof of noble birth in the maternal and paternal lines. Renascence rather than crisis or decline most accurately describes the Habsburg aristocracy during the Restoration and the Pre-March (1815-1848). One important facet of this renascence was the revival in the Hapsburg Empire of institutions such as the Teutonic Order and the Order of Malta for the socio-economic maintenance of noble agnates. These institutions had formerly spanned the Holy Roman Empire, but were not found in the other German states after 1815. Unlike the reform-proposals for the German nobility drawn up by statesmen such as Baron vom Stein, we can speak here of true ‘restoration’, as the Teutonic Order unmistakably maintained its pedigreed, Old-Regime aspect. Down to the collapse of the Monarchy, the Teutonic Order continued to provide valuable economic support to the less prosperous members of the Hapsburg aristocracy.

 

Margrit Grabas unter Mitarbeit von Paul W. Frey: Der vergessene Mittelstand — Entwicklung und Bedeutung kleiner und mittelgroßer Unternehmen an der Saar in der Zeit des krisenhaften Strukturwandels 1873—1894/95 (Band 89, Seite 41)

The Forgotten Middle Classes — The Development and Importance of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises in the Saar Region at the Time of Crises-Ridden Structural Changes form 1873 to 1894/95

 

The core of the present investigation involves more clearly determining the regional-economic importance in the Saar Region of small and medium-sized enterprises which had to cope with crisis-ridden structural changes from 1873 to 1894—95. Assuming that market process and enterprise development are reciprocally connected, our interest lies primarily in the question which strategies for market adjustment medium-sized enterprises employed to react to the challenge of the "Great Depression". By combining macro- and microeconomic methods, it can be demonstrated that small and medium-sized enterprises played a more important role in the socio-economic modernization of the Saar Region towards the end of the 19th century than has been conceded by economic-historical research: On the basis of technological and organizational changes small and medium-sized enterprises succeeded in expanding, especially in the manufacturing sector and, in this way, in breaking open an industrial structure dominated by coal and iron.

 

Dieter Hertz-Eichenrode: Die Feudalisierungsthese – ein Rückblick (Band 89, Seite 265)

The Feudalization – Theory reconsidered

 

The present article proceeds from the assumption that the so-called feudalization theory was a historiographic error. This theory maintains that between 1850 and 1918, a substantial segment of the German middle class, the bourgeoisie, abandoned its liberal positions in favour of pre-modern (that is, feudalistic) views.

The work is divided into four parts: 1) the rise of the feudalization theory and its revision via new critical research (1960–2000); 2) the development of the theory in the 19th century (1848–1918), whereby the work focuses on three components (political, socio-psychological and sociological); 3) the beginnings of an empirico-historical argumentation in support of the theory (1920–1960); and 4) some critical notes dealing with this theory – from a methodological standpoint – as a collective judgment levied on the German bourgeoisie, a judgment lacking adequate scholarly groundwork.

 

Laurent Heyberger: Gesundheit und Ernährung in Frankreich im 19. Jahrhundert (Band 90, Seite 316)

Health and Nutrition in Ninteenth-century France

 

Stature is a human development index. It allows to estimate the biological standard of living of the population of 19th century France. At that time, this population was mostly vegetarian. Several correlations point out a link between anthropometric data and nominal or real wheat prices between 1814 and 1847. However, the dependence was less important after 1834. The anthropometric improvement especially affects the poorest regions, south of a line that extends from Saint-Malo to Geneva.

 

Wolfgang König: Der Volksempfänger und die Radioindustrie. Ein Beitrag zum Verhältnis von Wirtschaft und Politik im Nationalsozialismus (Band 90, Seite 269)

The Volksempfänger and the Radio Receiver Industry: Politics and Economy in the Third Reich

 

In Nazi Germany a family of ‚people’s products’ was planned by which the National Socialists wished to demonstrate the forthcoming consumer society. The only ‚people’s product’ which was produced was the ‘Volksempfänger’, an inexpensive radio receiver. It was initiated by politics and designed and manufactured by industry. This article outlines the disputes between Nazi institutions, trade organisations, and business firms when developing and marketing the ‘Volksempfänger’. Particularly, it were the production numbers and the receiver’s price which resulted in enduring discussions. The article’s concern is to work out the reasons of the companies’ positions towards the ‘Volksempfänger’ as well as its economic outcome. The ‘Volksempfänger’-story is interpreted as an example for the interrelationship between Nazi-politics and the consumer goods-industry. try.

 

Christian Koller: Arbeit und Geschlecht in frühsozialistischen Zukunftsvorstellungen (Band 90, S. 141)

 

This article analyses the socialist thought of the first half of the 19th century in regard to the gender-specific division of work. Wilhelm Weitling’s and Etienne Cabet’s visions were based on essentialist gender categories and derived from a hierarchical order wherein men should dominate over women. Fourierism and Saint-Simonism also assumed essentialist categories, but they aimed at utilizing these in order to step up productivity and viewed the gendered division of labor in a non-hierachical manner. Only Robert Owen’s theory was neither essentialist nor hierarchical. Owen was deeply convinced that the human character was mainly formed by the environment, and he wanted – after a period of transition and education that would last several generations – to overcome all gender-specific divisions of labor.

 

Matthias Meinhardt: Magister Sebastian Leonhart (1544 – 1610). Bildungs- und Karriereweg eines wettinischen Fürstenlehrers und Hofbibliothekars (Band 90, S. 44)

 

Recently, there has been growing interest in the subject of education at court in medieval and early modern times. About the educators and tutors of young princes or dukes, however, fairly little certain knowledge is available. This is mainly due to a lack of sources which, in turn, can be attributed to the fact that education at court usually took place in seclusion.

Therefore, those few individual cases are very important in which outstandingly good sources allow to reconstruct the biography of an educator for the higher nobility. An example, which up to now has been scarcely noticed in recent work, is the biography of the Saxon tutor of princes and court librarian Sebastian Leonhart (1544–1610), which is described in the present essay. As a historical biography, it deals with the scholar’s own education and his career until his death, taking into account his social surroundings, relations to patrons and the conditions of upward mobility. Moreover, the ways and contents of education at court are also discussed within the biographical context.

 

Alexander Nützenadel: Wissenschaftliche Politikberatung in der Bundesrepublik. Die Gründung des Sachverständigenrates zur Begutachtung der gesamtwirtschaftlichen Lage 1963 (Band 89, Seite 288)

Scientific Policy Counseling in the Federal Republic. The Foundation of the Council for Economic Survey 1963

 

The article analyzes the political debates on the German Council for Economic Survey between 1958 and 1963. It is argued that through the "Sachverständigenrat", a new model of scientific policy counseling was established, which laid the foundation for the eminent role of economic expertise in the political discourse of the Federal Republic.

 

Jonas Scherner: Zwischen Staat und Markt. Die deutsche halbsynethetische Chemiefaserindustrie in den 1930er Jahren (Band 89, Seite 427)

Between State an Market. The German Rayon and Staple Fibre Industry in the 1930s

 

Between 1933 and 1939, autarky branches in Germany expanded significantly. The rayon and staple fibre industry was one of these branches. In difference to other autarky branches the semisynthetic fibres branch continued booming in West Germany after World War II. The literature suggests that the expansion of this branch in the 1930s was caused mainly by the incentives of the Nazi economic policy. Following this argumentation, the Nazi economic policy in this branch could be characterised as an at long sight successful industrialization policy. To test this hypothesis, I try to estimate the hypothetical German production of semisynthetic fibres assuming the counterfactual situation of Germany without autarchy policy. It can be demonstrated that the rayon and staple fibre production would also have expanded significantly without the specific Nazi economic policy.

 

Lil-Christine Schlegel-Voß / Gerd Hardach: Die dynamische Rente. Ein Modell der Alterssicherung im historischen Wandel Band 90/2003, Seite 290)

 

The social security reform of 1957 introduced dynamic pensions, which are institutionally linked to the increase of nominal wages, into the German social security system. Since then, dynamic pensions which provide an adequate income for the old generation are considered as one of the mainstays of the West German welfare state. However the concept of dynamic pensions is much older. It was first suggested in imperial Germany. Other dynamic pension systems were discussed, but not implemented at the beginning of the Weimar Republic, under the Nazi dictatorship, and in the German Democratic Republic. The aim of our article is to describe and discuss the historical evolution of the concept of dynamic pensions in Germany.

 

Florian Schui: Zur kritischen Analyse der neuen Institutionenökonomik: Douglass Norths Interpretation der frühmittelalterlichen Grundherrschaft (Band 90, S. 157)

 

The present article offers historical arguments for a critique of Douglass North’s institutional analysis of the medieval manor. On a first level the formal rigor of North’s argument is challenged. His argument focuses only on transaction costs without including other potential determinants of the institutional framework of the manor. Then it is examined whether North’s interpretation can be empirically verified ex post. The crucial point being the impossibility to quantitatively compare the two relevant forms of transaction costs. Finally, the article challenges North’s implicit and explicit assumptions about the Middle Ages on the base of the historical literature. The implicit assumptions challenged are the tendency of medieval man to adopt economically efficient institutions, and the ability of lord and serf to freely chose an institutional framework. The explicit assumptions challenged are the dominance of labour services among the obligations of the serf, the provision of effective protection by the lord, and the ‘rudimentary labor market’ that North sees for the serfs.

 

Margrit Schulte Beerbühl: Staatsangehörigkeit und fremdes Know-how. Die deutschen Kaufleute im britischen Russlandhandel des 18. Jahrhunderts (Band 89, Seite 379)

British Nationality and Foreign Know-how: German Merchants in Eighteenth-Century Anglo-Russian Trade

 

The fact that Great Britain became the foremost imperial and industrial power in the world was largely due to the supply of products grown and manufactured in Russia during the 18th century. The following article deals with the number of German merchants in the Anglo-Russian trade and their contribution to the upswing of the bilateral trade. It argues that in order to circumvent the vagaries and economic risks of the widely unknown Russian market Britain secured the help and superior knowledge of German merchants. On the one hand it obliged Germans to take up British nationality in order to secure a legal claim to their services. On the other hand it offered them attractive economic prospects and markets in exchange for their superior knowledge of Russian trade and trade practices.

 

Brigide Schwarz: Das Repertoirum Germanicum (Band 90, S. 429)

The Repertorium Germanicum

Oliver Volckart: Polykratische Wirtschaftspolitik: Zu den Beziehungen zwischen Wirtschaftsministerium, Arbeitsministerium, DAF und Reichsnährstand, 1933-1939 (Band 90, S. 174)

 

In this article, the hypothesis is examined that in the "Third Reich" bureaucratic agencies engaged in economic policies competed with each other. First, a model of competition is constructed whose predictions are then compared with actual political processes in Nazi-Germany. This shows that the bureaus indeed competed with each other, supplying Hitler with political support in exchange for rents. However, in contrast to what the model predicts, the bureaus did not adapt their policy supply to the dictator’s wishes. In order to explain this outcome, the paper examines how Hitler protected himself against competitors to himself and how his choice of strategy affected bureau competition.

 

Dirk Zeiseler: Die Bedeutung spanischer Eisenerze für die britische Rüstungsindustrie während des Ersten Weltkrieges (Band 89, Seite 167)

The Importance of Spanish Iron Ores for the British Armament Industrie during the First World War

 

This article examines the importance of Spanish iron ores for the British armament industry during the First World War in quantity and quality. It demonstrates that the British ability for warfare depended highly on the continuous and sufficient provision of Spanish iron ore for the manufacture of steel and ammunition. Therefore, the respective authorities in London tried to eliminate import impediments like tonnage shortage or export restrictions. At the same time Britain began to reduce the dependence on Spanish ores by introducing the flexible basic process in the steel industry. However, this strategy only succeeded in the last few months of the war. The British dependence on iron ore imports provided Spain an effective instrument to exert pressure on Britain which short-term strengthened the position of that neutral country in the calculation of British war policy.